Job Details

Insurance Customer Service Representative October 13, 2025

C919

Located in Cicero, IN

Pay: $18.00 - $22.00

Job Full Description

 

We have been asked by an Insurance Agency with offices in Cicero and Carmel, IN to help them find a Customer Service Representative.
In this role, you will provide exceptional service to insurance clients by answering questions, processing policy changes, and supporting the agency team in a fast-paced, detail-oriented environment.

 

Pay, Hours, and Benefits:

  • Pay: $18.00 - $22.00 per hour, based on experience
  • Schedule: Full-time, Monday–Friday, mainly at the Cicero office. Occasionally you will report to the Carmel office.
  • This is a contract-to-hire job opportunity. 
  • Benefits include:
    • 3 weeks Paid Time Off (120 hours), increasing to 4 weeks after 5 years
    • 9 Paid Holidays, including 2 Flex Holidays
    • 1 Paid Volunteer Day
    • Retirement Savings Plan with company match
    • Bonus opportunities
    • One approved work-from-home day (based on performance)
    • Career advancement and professional development support

What will you do as a Customer Service Representative?

  • Answer phones and consult with clients regarding insurance coverage, policy changes, and reviews
  • Provide prompt, courteous, and knowledgeable service
  • Work with insurance carrier systems, underwriters, lenders, and internal teams to create proposals and submit applications
  • Handle customer concerns and follow through to resolution
  • Maintain accurate records in the agency management system
  • Support the team with daily tasks and special projects
  • Participate in occasional community events (scheduled in advance)
  • Maintain a clean and professional office environment

What qualifications will you have as a Customer Service Representative?

  • Detail-oriented with a calm, professional demeanor
  • Passionate about educating and helping customers
  • Comfortable multitasking and managing multiple calls daily
  • Strong communicator who is personable, ethical, and trustworthy
  • Motivated to learn and grow in a dynamic team setting
  • Insurance experience is helpful but not required
  • Must obtain an insurance license in Auto, Home, and Life (training and first exam fee covered)
  • Must maintain license through continuing education (CE)
  • Proficient in Microsoft Office 365 and able to type quickly while on the phone

We look forward to working with you!

 

#INOS

Fishers (Indianapolis North), IN
2275
7259 Fishers Landing Drive
Fishers, IN 46038

Apply Now Email Us

Close